7 Signs You're Underpaid (And Exactly How Much to Ask For)
The 7 Warning Signs
You haven't gotten a real raise in 18+ months
If your only "raises" have been cost-of-living adjustments (COLA) of 2-3%, you've effectively taken a pay cut. Inflation-adjusted terms, you need at least a 4-5% annual increase just to stay even. More than 18 months without a meaningful raise = you're falling behind.
New hires with less experience earn as much (or more) than you
This is the clearest possible sign. If a junior hire's offer is within 10% of what you make after 3+ years at the company, your salary has been eroded by below-market annual increases. Companies often pay market rate for new hires while letting long-term employees' wages stagnate.
You're doing work beyond your job description — regularly
Are you handling tasks from a higher-level role? Training new team members? Leading projects? Taking on extra responsibilities without a title or pay change? That's called scope creep, and it's a leading indicator of being undervalued.
Your salary is below the 50th percentile for your role + experience + location
Use Glassdoor, Levels.fyi, and LinkedIn Salary Insights to check where you fall. If you're consistently in the bottom half despite strong performance reviews, you have hard data for a conversation.
You can't answer "what's your target compensation?" confidently
If someone asked you right now what you should be earning and you'd have to guess, you haven't done your homework. Knowing your market value is step zero. We'll show you how to calculate it below.
Your employer has had a profitable year but mentions "tight budgets" when you ask about raises
"Budget constraints" is corporate-speak for "we don't prioritize paying you fairly." If the company is profitable, growing, or hiring new people at market rates while telling you there's no money for raises — that's a red flag.
You feel anxious about checking your bank account before large purchases
This isn't a data point — it's a gut check. Financial stress despite working full-time in a skilled role is a symptom of underpayment. Your labor should provide financial stability plus room for savings.
How to Calculate Your True Market Value
Don't guess. Follow this 4-step method to arrive at a defensible target number:
- Gather 5+ data points — Check Glassdoor, Levels.fyi, LinkedIn Salary Insights, Indeed, and Blind for your exact title + city. Write down each range.
- Adjust for your specific factors:
- +10-20% if you have specialized certifications or rare skills
- +5-15% if you consistently exceed performance expectations
- -5-10% if you're in a lower-COL area (but remember: remote work changes this)
- +0-10% if your company is in a high-growth sector (AI, biotech, clean energy)
- Calculate the midpoint — Throw out the highest and lowest outlier, average the remaining 3+, and add 10%. That's your target ask.
- Model it with our calculator — Enter your target salary in our Salary Survival Engine to see exactly what your take-home pay would look like. Use this data in negotiations.
Salary Benchmarks: What to Ask For (By Experience Level)
These are national averages for full-time salaried roles in the United States (2026). Adjust ±20-40% based on your location:
| Experience | Entry-Level | Mid-Level | Senior | Lead/Principal |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Software Engineer | $75-95k | $120-160k | $170-230k | $250-350k+ |
| Product Manager | $80-100k | $130-170k | $180-240k | $260-320k+ |
| Marketing Manager | $55-70k | $85-115k | $120-155k | $160-200k |
| Data Analyst | $60-75k | $90-120k | $125-160k | $165-210k |
| HR Generalist | $48-58k | $65-85k | $88-110k | $115-140k |
| Graphic Designer | $45-55k | $62-82k | $85-110k | $115-145k |
* These reflect base salaries only. Total compensation (equity, bonus, benefits) can add 20-60% at tech companies.
The Location Multiplier: Why $90k in Texas > $110k in California
We built a tool specifically for this. Compare what your salary buys across states:
- $100k in California: ~$5,800/mo take-home, ~$2,200 rent → $3,600 left
- $90k in Texas: ~$5,700/mo take-home, ~$1,300 rent → $4,400 left
- $85k in Florida: ~$5,400/mo take-home, ~$1,250 rent → $4,150 left
🔢 See What YOU Should Be Earning
Enter any salary and any state. Get your exact take-home pay, affordability score, and percentile ranking instantly. Free. No signup required.
Calculate Your Worth Now →